Borrillo's pizza is great! My husband and I try to visit once a week if we can (though lately money has been a bit too tight). They have great prices and a wonderful lunch special. Two can split the lunch special (which is two slices and a drink) and there's plenty of food. Order one slice - it will fill your plate!!
Have tried several things on their menu, the white pie is very tasty, if all else fails the pepperoni is great too. We love to get the antipasto if we can!
Highly recommend Borrillo's to anyone in town. Hands down, the best pizza in Saint Augustine. :)