A DAY WITHOUT BROOKLYN PIZZA IS LIKE A DAY WITHOUT SUNSHINE. Brooklyn Pizza a San Jose Blvd.. ha la pizza migliore della città, giù le mani! A Day Without Brooklyn Pizza è come un giorno senza sole! Se avessi potuto fare un bagno nella salsa pizza lo farei! NON RILASCIANO ALCUNA GARANZIA SU ERRORE SI, Da New York a Jamaica la torta in questo negozio avrà i tuoi Mind Right! Il piccolo ragazzo con gli occhiali e capelli bianchi fa una buona pizza troppo. Dove l'uomo nero con i capelli lunghi?
Tony is Brooklyn.
The original. The cleanest. The friendliest. The best. Enough said.
All who disagree, Vafancul!
Have a nice day.
Best friggin pizza in Jacksonville forgettaboutit. Hello I want to comment the 9A location. I don't know why everyone's complainig about it. Here's a few starters for those who complained about that place. Tell me where else in Jacksonville are you going to find Garlic knots or pinwheels? Also there are not too many places serving sicilian either. I have been to these so called N.Y pizzaria's like Al's and Renna's and they certainly do not have this in there establishments. Now I too am an ex New yorker from the Island and this place is as good if not better than most places I have been to up there. Secondly cosider what I just said earlier where are you goign to find pinwheels and garlic knots in Jacksonville. I hope all of you will consider this before posting another thumbs down review on someone. I have pearsonally eaten in this establishment and I love it there. Secondly to keep in true N.Y tradition there is a Carvell Icecream store right next door. I have lived here for almost 6 years and this is the first place to have anything like garlic knots pinwheels etc... I visit up north often and this is just as good if not better.
Not quite New Yorker Pizza..
This review is for Brooklyn Pizza at Baymeadows and 9A. I went to school in New York so I know what New York style Pizza should be like. The first time I went to this joint, I thought the Pizza was probable the closest thing I can get to New York pizza. But that was about it. The last 4 or more times that I came back the pizza was like any other pizza in town. You know the one. They call themselves New York pizza but it doesn't even come close. The only thing I can think of my first experience was the manager claim the pie makers were from Brooklyn. This is probable true because the first Pizza was pretty darn good. I haven't seen that guy ever since then though.
I wouldn't recommend this place for true New Yorker's in Jacksonville.
Editorial Review by Christy Buena. Restaurant serves calzones, pizza, strombolis and subs in a trendy restaurant located in an upper middle class neighborhood.
I lived in Jersey for over 25 yrs and grew up on New Style Pizza and even worked in a pizza joint as a young adult and have tasted the best NY Pizza in the world and the so called Brooklyn Pizza can't even come close. I oredered a large meatlovers pizza at the Point Meadows new store it was horrible. Under cooked, very little cheese, dry, cheese was cheap no oils at all. Yes there was a nice portion of diff meats but it cost $20 dollars which is riduculous . Sorry guys, but you have some nerve calling yourselves Brooklyn Pizza unless your referring to Brooklyn, Iowa !!!!!!!!!!!! Maybe you guys should go to Pizzatown on Rt. 46 in Elmwood Park, new jersey and try some real pizza and zeppoli's.
A Jersey Doo Wopper !!!!!!!!!
A JERSEY GIRLS REVIEW. I HAVE EATEN ALOT OF PIZZA IN JACKSONVILLE , BUT HAVE NEVER HAD AND THAT RESEMBLED NY STYLE PIZZA. THAT IS UNTIL I WENT TO BROOKLYN PIZZA ON OLD ST AUGUSTINE BLVD, BY I-95. IT IS TRUELY THE BEST IN JACKSONVILLE. AND I AM NOT A FRIEND OF ANYONE THAT OWNES OR WORKES THERE. SO FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO MISS NY PIZZA STOP LOOKING AND GO TO BROOKLYN PIZZA !!!
N.Y. Italians Meet Here. Tony and Angela are the sweethearts of Jax pizza. They are real Italians from Bari, Italy by way of N.Y., who make REAL ITALIAN N.Y. PIZZA. The place is spotless. The pizza will bring a tear to your eye if you are from N.Y. "You CAN go home again!!!" And, now I heard that they are opening a second location at the Kohl's shopping center on I-95. Make sure to order ahead by phone on Friday and Saturday nites or else you WILL BE eating pizza standing up.
FROM THE HEART. THANK YOU BROOKLYN PIZZA FOR A WONDERFUL PIZZA,SERVICE,AND A VERY VERY CLEAN ESTABLISHMENT. WOW! YOU GUYS ARE #1 WITH ME ALWAYS. HOW IN THE WORLD YOU'RE NOT VOTED THE BEST PIZZA IN JACKSONVILLE IS BEYOND ME! BROOKLYN PIZZA SHOULD BE THE STANDARD FOR EVERY PIZZA PLACE IN THIS TOWN,HANDS DOWN! WE'LL VISIT THREE TIMES A WEEK AS USUAL. ONCE AGAIN,"THANK YOU SO MUCH!"
ambience ????. The traditional pizzeria is not a restaurant in the sense that it has tablecloths and mood lighting. It has to be clean, well lit, and stocked with the few necessary spices that are used with pizza: crushed peppers, cheese, and oregano.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!